Pigeonholing: Why we make hasty judgments

You hear a few words, you see a gesture - and presto: you have a picture of a person. Welcome to the Pigeonhole thinking. This widespread thought pattern helps us to categorize the world more quickly. But it comes at a price. Because what gives us orientation can also separate, limit and prevent development.

In this article, we show you how pigeonholing arises, why it is so persistent - and, above all, how you can break free from it.

The psychology of pigeonholing

Pigeonholing is an automatic mechanism of our brain. It simplifies complex information by dividing it into categories. Psychologists refer to this as Schemesmental structures that help to process experiences more quickly.

But what begins as a protective mechanism can quickly become an obstacle - especially if we:

  • Judging people by outward appearances,
  • Reduce personality traits to roles ("typical teacher, typical woman"),
  • keep ourselves small because we think we "don't fit into a certain box".

This form of thinking has profound consequences - for our self-image, our relationships and our personal development.

Why do we think in pigeonholes?

Pigeonholing is deeply rooted in our evolutionary history. Our brain loves quick decisions - they ensure survival. Even today, pigeonholing helps us to react quickly in social situations. However, this speed is often based on incomplete information and assumptions.

Reasons for pigeonholing:

  • Cognitive relief: Our brain saves energy if it does not have to re-evaluate each time.
  • Social imprinting: We learn many stereotypes in childhood - through parents, school or the media.
  • Fear of the unknown: New things irritate. Pigeonholing provides security, even if it is deceptive.

"The more complex the world, the more seductive pigeonholing becomes." Greator Life Coach Christina Hommelsheim

A woman sits at her table and puts something in a drawer: it is symbolic of how we are often quick to judge people and think in pigeonholes.

Which drawers do we unconsciously use?

Even if we think we are open-minded, we have unconsciously internalized many categories. These include, for example:

1. social role models

Examples: "Men are rational", "Women are emotional", "Older people are less capable".

2. origin and appearance

Examples: "People with dialect are less educated", "Tattooed people are rebellious".

3. occupational groups

Examples: "Salespeople are pushy", "Psychologists are always analyzing".

These stereotypes may seem harmless - but they have a significant influence, how we treat others and how we are allowed to think for ourselves.

What are the consequences of pigeonholing?

Pigeonholing not only influences our opinions, but also our behavior:

  • We underestimate other peoplebecause we reduce them to a label.
  • We sabotage ourselvesbecause we consider ourselves "unsuitable" for certain paths.
  • We block developmentbecause there is no room for new perspectives.
  • We reproduce prejudiceseven if we do not consciously share them.

Studies in social psychology show that implicit stereotypes influence our decisions - even if we perceive ourselves as tolerant.

How do I recognize my own pigeonholing?

Self-reflection is the first step. Ask yourself:

  • Which people spontaneously trigger rejection in me - and why?
  • Which "types" do I particularly like - and what project I on them?
  • At what moments do I try to "fit into a pigeonhole"?

👉 Note: Use our free of charge Vision Challenge Workbook. It helps you to recognize your own thought patterns - and to develop your own personal vision.

Ways out of pigeonholing

You can consciously open your mind. Here are a few strategies:

1. observe your thoughts - without judgment

Pay attention to your spontaneous associations. Not to condemn them, but to to consciously perceive.

2. seek contact with "other worlds"

The more you talk to people who "don't fit into your box", the more your perspective will broaden.

3. change your language

Language influences thinking. Avoid blanket statements such as "typical woman" or "all millennials" - they create stereotypes without you even realizing it.

4. reflect on your self-image

In which drawer do you see yourself? And what new role would you like to take on? Perhaps now is the time to define this role.

Can coaching help with pigeonholing?

Yes - and on several levels. Coaching supports you in this, old Recognize beliefsquestion your self-image and adopt new perspectives. At Greator, many coaches work with precisely these topics: How to free yourself from old thought structures - and thus find your own path.

If you would like to reflect on your thought patterns, we recommend our free Vision Challenge Workbook. It guides you in three simple steps to greater clarity about your goals and Visions.

Conclusion: Out of the drawer - into your real life

Pigeonholing happens - often quite automatically. But you have the choice whether you stay in it or free yourself from it. It takes courage to recognize your own errors in thinking. But this is precisely where the greatest opportunity lies: consciously changing your view of the world - and of yourself.

Because your real life begins beyond the drawers.

➡️ Your next step: Understand yourself better

Do you want to develop yourself further - free from old labels and frameworks? Then start with our free Personality Test. It helps you to find your individual Behavioural patterns to understand yourself, recognize your strengths and see yourself in a new light. Because only those who know themselves can really leave pigeonholing behind: Click here for the personality test

Free personality test

In only 5 minutes you will find out, what personality type you are.
Start free trial

Like this article? Don't forget to share!

Worth reading: Recommendations from the Greator experts
GREATOR MAGAZINE
Greator Slogan: It's in youGreator awards: Innovation Champion 2024 from Focus, Kununu Top Company 2023-2025, Great Place to Work certified 2020-2024 and World's Best Employer 2023.
Greator Slogan: It's in youGreator awards: Innovation Champion 2024 from Focus, Kununu Top Company 2023-2025, Great Place to Work certified 2020-2024 and World's Best Employer 2023.
Helpcenter
Imprint
Data privacy
GTC
Cookie settings
© copyright by Greator 2025
chevron-down