The day is over, the to-do list is checked off, and yet my mind is still racing.
You're sitting on the sofa. Your mind says, "Everything's fine." Your body says something else.
It is precisely this breakdown that the polyvagal theory describes. It explains why you inner peace You can't just decide to do it. And it's so scientifically controversial that you should only use it with an open mind.
The most important facts in brief
The Polyvagal Theory is a model proposed by Stephen Porges in 1994 that distinguishes three states of the nervous system: safety, alarm, and shutdown.
Neuroception refers to your nervous system's unconscious assessment of whether a situation is safe or threatening.
In a 2026 evaluation, a group of 39 experts concluded that the core neurophysiological tenets of the polyvagal theory are untenable.
Taking a long, slow breath, consciously looking around the room, and making calm eye contact with others can help calm your body, even if the theory behind it remains controversial.
What is the Polyvagal Theory?
The polyvagal theory is an explanatory model proposed by Stephen Porges in 1994, according to which the autonomic nervous system controls three states via the vagus nerve: social connection and safety, fight or flight, and freeze.
To this end, Porges divides the parasympathetic nervous system into two branches of the vagus nerve: an older dorsal branch and a younger ventral branch. The model is based on three principles:
Hierarchy means: Your nervous system falls back on older protective mechanisms when the newer ones aren't enough.
Neuroception means that your nervous system constantly and unconsciously checks whether your surroundings are safe.
Co-regulation means: A sense of security is conveyed through the voices, gazes, and physical presence of other people.
According to the polyvagal theory, Emotional stability not through willpower, but through a nervous system that perceives safety.
The three states you recognize in everyday life
The model does not describe personality types. It describes states, and you switch between them several times a day.
Safety. You are calm, curious, and approachable. You listen, think clearly, and are able to connect with people.
Alarm. Your heart is racing, your jaw is clenched, your thoughts are racing—you’re irritable or on edge. Monday, 9:00 a.m., three appointments, and an unresolved conflict: that’s what this state is like. A pounding heart, shallow breathing, and muscle tension are among the typical Physical symptoms this phase.
Shutdown. You withdraw, feel a sense of emptiness and heaviness, and nothing seems to go right anymore. In this model, long periods of alarm are often followed by a state of shutdown, and those who end up there often feel Emotionally drained.
In this model, stress isn't a character flaw, but rather a physical state, and physical states can be changed.
Is the polyvagal theory scientifically proven?
Based on current knowledge, the core neurophysiological claims of the polyvagal theory are not considered to be substantiated. Whether the model is nevertheless useful as a conceptual framework remains a matter of perspective.
In the February 2026 issue of Clinical Neuropsychiatry An expert evaluation led by Paul Grossman was published. Thirty-nine experts in physiology, the evolution of the vagus nerve, and the social behavior of vertebrates examined five key points, such as the assumption that respiratory sinus arrhythmia directly measures vagal tone in the heart. They found that none of the five points was supported by the evidence. Their conclusion: The theory is "untenable," meaning it cannot be sustained.
Proponents counter that the criticism evaluates the model solely from a neurophysiological perspective and ignores its clinical benefits.
Doctors Caroline Giroux and Daniel Ahlers appear in the Journal of Psychiatry Reform (2023) reached a different conclusion regarding practical application: While the theory is biologically questionable, it serves as a useful paradigm for recovery from trauma.
There is no dispute that the vagus nerve controls the heart and digestion. What is disputed is whether it regulates these three states in the way Porges describes.
The polyvagal theory is a conceptual model, not a proven mechanism, and that's how you should use it. In this article, we'll treat it exactly that way.
Why Your Mind Can't Convince Your Body
You can tell yourself a hundred times that everything is fine. But if your body remains on high alert, it won't believe you.
That explains why New Year's resolutions so often fail in the evening. Anyone who tries to, Control emotions, operates on the level of thoughts. The body's condition often remains unaffected by this. Also Suppressing feelings usually doesn't change it.
Calm often begins in the body, not in an argument.
Eva Kaczor, creator of the PSYCHEDELIC BREATH® method, describes breathwork as a path to genuine, embodied change: change that you experience in your body, rather than just deciding upon in your mind.
You've known for a long time that you should relax, but your body just won't cooperate.
The free „Vision & Breathwork“ masterclass with Eva Kaczor guides you toward inner clarity through breathing—that is, through the body rather than through more thinking.
These three exercises are simple practices for everyday life. Their benefits do not depend on whether the polyvagal theory is correct.
1. Exhale longer than you inhale. Breathe in through your nose for four seconds and breathe out through your mouth for six to eight seconds. Repeat this for two minutes.
Your breath is the fastest switch you can control yourself without any tools.
In a randomized study involving 108 participants (Balban et al., *Cell Reports Medicine*, 2023) The breathing exercise known as “Cyclic Sighing”—two short inhalations followed by one long exhalation—increased positive mood more significantly than mindfulness meditation over a 28-day period. The study was small and exploratory. It provides a hint, not proof. If you’re interested in breathing exercises beyond these two minutes, you can find more information here: Breathwork.
2. Orient the room. Let your gaze wander slowly around the room and name five things you see. According to the logic of this model, this signals to your nervous system that there is no danger at the moment.
3. Find a connection. Talk to someone you feel safe with, and pay attention to a calm voice—both theirs and yours. Serenity is transmitted, according to the co-regulation hypothesis.
Stop if you feel dizzy. If you have any pre-existing medical conditions, talk to your doctor first.
What remains of the polyvagal theory?
The polyvagal theory is controversial as a mechanism but useful as a metaphor. It reminds you that you don’t just have thoughts—you also have a body that needs to feel safe before it can let go.
That's not fate. You can influence your situation, and you don't have to believe in any theory to do so.
Start now: Take three breaths, and make sure your exhalation lasts twice as long as your inhalation.